AM Best: stricter delegated authority audits the new normal. The old coal claim a $130M lesson for every front. And the day a machine that acts on its own breaks something.


This week, November 20, 2026. 01 The capacity file. How to keep your capacity when AM Best says stricter audits are becoming standard 02 The machine record. How to prepare for the day a machine that acts on its own breaks something 03 The front. How to know what your reinsurance covers behind a front, after a judge ruled Swiss Re owes $129.75 million

Skim time: 5 minutes · Listening time: 7 minutes. Prefer to listen? Flip reads this week's Brief here.

This week I had several underwriter meetings, two claims calls, and one long conversation with an insurance company client about bordereau reporting. It sounds kind of boring, but it was the opposite.

Meanwhile, AI is on every agenda. It's in most of the pitches in my inbox. I use it, and in a lot of ways it's helping our business. In so many more, I think it's robbing the soul of what has always made this business great. The analog. The people stuff that's just always made this business work.

Take those underwriter meetings. They were still a client and an underwriter talking directly. A lot of them are confidential, so we don't allow the AI notetakers that are now pervasive on every call.

And the bordereau? We've done it the same way my entire career. The client collects the information, it goes into a spreadsheet, and it goes to the carrier. It doesn't need AI. It doesn't need quantum computing. It just works, because people do their part on time, including telling us about circumstances before they blow up.

I almost wrote about IBM's new survey this week: only 12% of insurers are getting high returns from AI. Then I decided we've all heard enough about AI for one week. If you're sitting through another AI demo wondering what it fixes, hit reply.

So this week, the Brief is about the people and the paperwork that decide who pays:

  • AM Best says the carriers behind MGAs now want reliable, timely reporting, and stricter audits are becoming standard. That's my bordereau call, in a rating agency's words.
  • When a machine that acts on its own breaks something, it's the people fixing it.
  • A federal judge just ruled Swiss Re owes $129.75 million on reinsurance written in the early 1980s. One paragraph in a 2017 letter is a big reason why, and it's a lesson for everyone involved with a fronting company.

·   ·   ·

 
Article 01

How to keep your capacity when AM Best says stricter audits are becoming standard

AM Best says the carriers behind MGAs are checking the paperwork harder.

On November 10, AM Best kept a stable outlook on MGAs (managing general agents), the firms that write policies in a carrier's name with the carrier's permission. They wrote $108.7 billion in direct premium in 2025, up 17.8% by AM Best's count, the fifth straight year of double-digit growth. AM Best expects it to slow.

The reason is oversight.

Regulators hold the carrier responsible for customers and compliance, even after it lets an MGA write on its behalf, so the checking falls on the carrier. AM Best says the carriers and their reinsurers now want steady results, strong controls and "reliable and timely reporting." Its senior director, Jacqalene Lentz, says "stricter governance and audit requirements are becoming standard."

Capacity, the premium a carrier will let an MGA write, is still there, but AM Best calls it "increasingly partner specific."

Carriers are sorting steady MGAs from volatile ones, and renewal terms are tightening. New money is arriving through fronting and quota shares, and AM Best says carriers are more careful there too. The National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) uses a wider measure, all U.S. surplus lines business whoever writes it, and that reached $143.3 billion in 2025, more than three times 2016.

Line chart: U.S. surplus lines premium more than tripled, from $42.6 billion in 2016 to $143.3 billion in 2025. Source: NAIC, U.S. Surplus Lines Industry Report, 2025 data year.

That's the wider market many MGAs write into. The more of it that runs on someone else's pen, the more a carrier has to check.

The bordereau, the regular report of the policies, premium and claims an MGA sends its carrier, is now part of how a carrier judges you.

(sources: AM Best, Market Segment Outlook: Delegated Underwriting Authority Enterprises; Risk & Insurance; Insurance Journal; chart: NAIC, The 2025 Surplus Lines Industry)

So what?

If you let an MGA write in your name, the regulator holds you responsible for what it does. Read your program agreement for the lines, limits and claims authority you granted, your audit rights, and how fast you'd see a breach. Then check that the MGA's errors and omissions (E&O) limit fits that authority. It may be your main recovery.

If you're the MGA, AM Best says capacity goes to firms with clear authority rules and reliable reporting: a bordereau that ties to your premium trust account every month, and a referral log for every risk written outside your authority, with the approval attached. Auditors sample files, and that log is what they pull.

When an audit finds a breach, the carrier's demand usually comes under the indemnity in your agency agreement. Check whether your E&O covers claims from your own carriers and loss from exceeding your authority, since many forms exclude or sublimit both. Premium you hold for a carrier is a crime and fidelity question, not an E&O one. And E&O and crime forms generally don't pay for a lost binding authority.

Ask your board: If our capacity partner audited us next month, could we hand over reconciled bordereaux and a referral log for every risk written outside our authority? If we're the carrier, who reads our MGAs' reports, and would we catch a breach before the loss ratio did?

An auditor can pull your referral log. The next log that matters may be a machine's, and it can be gone within hours.

·   ·   ·

 
Article 02

How to prepare for the day a machine that acts on its own breaks something

On November 13, a router helped ground American air travel.

The Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) stopped departures nationwide for more than four hours, and FlightAware counted more than 9,000 U.S. cancellations that day, CNBC reported. Officials tied it to router work in Arkansas and said they found no evidence AI was involved. For the airlines downstream, that's business interruption with no physical damage, which most property forms won't pay, and cyber pays only if the outage hits a provider the policy covers, often under a sublimit.

In a Law360 commentary this week, James Malackowski of J.S. Held asks what happens when the system decides, acts and moves machinery by itself, what he calls physical AI.

The claims will be familiar, he writes. What's new is the proof. Sensor data, logs and model versions can be overwritten within hours, and a routine restart can change the very thing you need to examine.

His examples have already happened.

The National Transportation Safety Board is investigating a January crash in which a Waymo struck a 9-year-old in a Santa Monica school zone, using school and vehicle cameras. After a Cruise robotaxi dragged a pedestrian about 20 feet in 2023, Cruise's first report to regulators left that out, and Cruise paid a $1.5 million penalty to NHTSA, the federal auto-safety regulator, plus a $500,000 fine under a deferred prosecution agreement. Crash reports like that are now routine: companies running self-driving vehicles reported 1,023 crashes to NHTSA in 2025, up from 163 in 2022.

Column chart: crashes involving self-driving vehicles reported to NHTSA grew more than sixfold, 163 in 2022, 288 in 2023, 549 in 2024 and 1,023 in 2025. A report is not a finding of fault. Source: NHTSA Standing General Order crash reports, automated driving systems.

Each of those reports is a record someone may later have to defend. A report is not a finding of fault.

Cruise was penalized for the gap between what the machine recorded and what the company told regulators.

(sources: Law360, Malackowski; CNBC; NTSB; TechCrunch; chart: NHTSA, Standing General Order crash reporting)

The LION Lens

Malackowski's warning lands in three places in a typical program.

The log. It can be overwritten within hours, and your policies still expect you to give notice and help the insurer investigate. Cyber usually pays for forensics after a security event. If it's a malfunction, not an attack, ask whether any policy pays to preserve the record before anyone sues, and who, on your side or the vendor's, can freeze it.

The injury. Cyber usually excludes bodily injury, and general liability and product forms may exclude electronic data or cyber incidents. Malackowski says the loss can fall between them. Ask which policy answers first, and whether each one excludes what the other assumes it covers.

The account. When what the company tells a regulator doesn't match what the machine recorded, D&O may respond to the investigation, subject to its exclusions for deliberate misconduct. Make sure every statement to a regulator or insurer comes from one fact record.

So what?

If you write this risk, AM Best names AI-enabled industries and self-driving transport as classes where MGAs find both opportunity and volatility. Ask Malackowski's questions for the insured: can they rebuild what happened, which policy responds, and who investigates?

If you use these systems, a claims bot, a vendor's agent or a rating engine that binds without a person can break the same way. For an MGA, an automated bind outside authority is the breach your carrier's auditor is looking for. My notice point applies twice: preserve the machine data within hours, and tell the carrier before you hire forensics, because its consent is often what gets that work paid.

The LION POV

Malackowski says to settle these gaps "with the broker and carriers before deployment." Here's what we're raising with clients who deploy or insure these systems:

  • Map the record before go-live. Good is a list of every log, who controls it (you or the vendor), how long it's kept against the fastest overwrite, and a contract right to make the vendor preserve it. The tell: the litigation hold goes to people, and nobody tells the systems.
  • Walk one malfunction through every policy. Good is a written test of an injury-plus-shutdown loss, with no attacker, through cyber, general liability, product, property and E&O, including who pays to retrain a bad model. The tell: each policy assumes another one pays.
  • Keep one fact record. Good is every statement to a regulator, insurer or counterparty tied to the same preserved data, with corrections dated. The tell: the notice to your insurer says something your regulatory filing doesn't.

Ask your board: If one of our automated systems hurt someone tomorrow, could we rebuild what it did within hours, and which of our policies would answer first?

A machine's log can vanish in hours. The paper behind a front can wait more than 40 years for its test.

·   ·   ·

 
Article 03

How to know what your reinsurance covers behind a front, after a judge ruled Swiss Re owes $129.75 million

Most of you skimmed this one, and I don't blame you.

If you read it as a 1980s coal ash story, a dry reinsurance fight over contracts from 40 years ago, you'd skip it too. Read it as a fronting story. Fronting is when a licensed carrier issues the policy in its own name while someone else carries the risk behind it.

In 1982, Ranger Insurance fronted six excess policies for Duke Energy on behalf of AEGIS, the utility mutual, which wasn't yet admitted in North Carolina.

Ranger reinsured each one with what is now Swiss Reinsurance America: six facultative certificates, $130 million in limits. AEGIS handled the claims for 34 years, the court found, and reported the policies on its quarterly bordereaux. In 2016, Duke gave notice of coal ash claims.

Under a 2017 letter, AEGIS took over the defense and settlement, and one paragraph in it, added at the insistence of Ranger's successor, TIG, kept TIG's rights against Swiss Re.

AEGIS settled with Duke for $185 million in 2021. TIG assigned its reinsurance claim to AEGIS, which billed Swiss Re for a 57% share plus expenses. Swiss Re refused, arguing its certificates covered only the front's own risk, the chance AEGIS couldn't pay.

After a nine-day trial, Judge Nelson Román of the federal court in Manhattan disagreed.

The certificates reinsure the policy liability on their face. Swiss Re couldn't use the TIG and AEGIS letter, which it never signed, to get out of them, and the 57% allocation was reasonable and made in good faith. On November 12 he found Swiss Re owes $129,750,677, plus interest from November 2021.

Bar chart: 44 years from the 1982 reinsurance certificates to the court's ruling. AEGIS paid the claims for 34 years, notice to settlement took 5, settlement to ruling took 5. Judgment is not yet entered and may be appealed. Source: U.S. District Court, S.D.N.Y., TIG v. Swiss Reinsurance America, November 12, 2026.

For 34 years the certificates sat quietly behind the front. It took ten more to find out what they covered.

One paragraph in a 2017 letter helped keep $130 million of reinsurance collectible, at least at trial.

(sources: TIG Insurance Co. v. Swiss Reinsurance America Corp., No. 7:21-cv-08975 (S.D.N.Y.), findings of fact and conclusions of law; Law360)

So what?

Keep it in proportion: this is one trial court applying New York law to these certificates. The judgment hasn't been entered yet, and Swiss Re can appeal.

For TIG and then AEGIS, this was money owed by a reinsurer and in dispute for five years. A balance that size is a reserve, capital and rating conversation, and the call to sue or write it down belongs to the board. If that decision is later challenged, it becomes a question for your directors and officers (D&O) insurance.

If you front, check two lines in your reinsurance: whether it covers your liability under the policy or only the share you keep, and whether expenses sit inside the limit or on top of it.

If you hand claims control to a partner, take it from one, or settle, end a reinsurance contract early or sell a book, read your reinsurance before you sign. The court found AEGIS's own counsel acknowledged AEGIS didn't fully appreciate the certificates when it signed the 2017 letter. TIG did, and its paragraph is a large part of why the court found the reinsurance collectible.

Ask your board: When we last signed a claims-handling, fronting or settlement agreement, did anyone read our reinsurance alongside it, and does the agreement say in writing that our recoveries survive?

·   ·   ·

The Bottom Line

A bordereau, a robotaxi's camera, a side letter. In each story, the record is deciding who pays.

Start with the paper you already own: your delegated authority agreements, the incident plan for any system that acts without a person, and the reinsurance behind any front. Read each against what you actually do, and settle the gaps with your counsel and broker before someone tests them. Over the next year, watch for tighter audit terms in delegated authority renewals and for a Swiss Re appeal.

Three for your board on Monday

  1. The capacity file. Could we hand a carrier reconciled bordereaux and a referral log for every risk written outside our authority?
  2. The machine record. Who can freeze our systems' logs within hours, ours and our vendors', and which policy pays first?
  3. The front. When we last signed a claims, fronting or settlement agreement, did anyone read our reinsurance alongside it, and does it say in writing that our recoveries survive?

Give each question an owner, and ask for a written answer at least 150 days before your next renewal.

·   ·   ·

ICYMI: Wednesday's E&O note asked whether your E&O describes the work your MGA actually does. It's the same question as Article 1, from the other side of the contract.

·   ·   ·

Thank you for reading today's edition.

Want to share it? Copy the link below:

https://lionspecialty.kit.com/posts/am-best-stricter-delegated-authority-audits-the-new-normal-the-old-coal-claim-a-130m-lesson-for-every-front-and-the-day-a-machine-that-acts-on-its-own-breaks-something

And if this was forwarded to you, subscribe here.

Stay Covered Everybody,

-FLIP

P.S. Want us to read your delegated authority agreements, your reinsurance behind a front, or your program against an automated-system scenario before your next renewal? Reach out for a confidential conversation: book a time or reply to this email.

P.P.S. Nothing in this briefing constitutes legal advice. These are the opinions of the founder, and coverage is always subject to the terms of each policy. It's market intelligence designed to help you ask better questions of your advisors and make sharper decisions at your next insurance renewal.

Boardroom Brief. Three articles. Five minutes. Friday, 7 a.m. Lloyd's of London from below.
LION Specialty. 800 Third Avenue, #1488, New York, NY 10022 · lionspecialty.com

You're receiving this because you subscribed to the LION Specialty Boardroom Brief.
Unsubscribe  ·  Update your preferences
Forwarded this, or unsubscribed by mistake? Subscribe here.

LION Specialty

Everything you need to know to navigate the financial institution insurance market in ≈ 5 minutes per week. Delivered on Fridays.

Read more from LION Specialty

Skim time: 6 minutes · Listening time: 6 minutes. Prefer to listen? Flip reads this week’s Brief here. If you and I were chopping it up this week, here's what I'd bring up. First, cyber. The headline is that policies jumped by a third. But nearly two-thirds of them are endorsements that average about $80. $80! I don't care how many of those got sold. I want to know what one pays when your controller sends a wire to a fraudster. Second, a New York bad faith case every insurance operator should...

21 insurers and brokers talked AI tools on their calls. Three talked exclusions. New York set its bar. And AI agents are filling out your quote forms.

Skim time: 8 minutes · Listening time: 6 minutes. Prefer to listen? Flip reads this week’s Brief here. Earnings season is basically over for our corner of the market, and AI came up on almost every call. Mostly as a way to save money. Of 28 public insurers and brokers, 21 talked about AI as a tool. Three talked about AI exclusions, and only because an analyst asked. On the financial institution renewals we’re placing, we haven’t seen AI-specific exclusions. Not yet. That’s the half management...

This week’s software emergency, vendor breach and insurance report point to the same question.

Skim time: 7 minutes · Listening time: 6 minutes. Prefer to listen? Flip reads this week’s Brief here. This week, the software behind a big chunk of the internet needed an emergency fix. That includes a lot of insurer, MGA and insurtech websites. PHP is a three-letter acronym nobody had heard of a week ago. Now we all know way too much about it. We also found out hackers had stolen a key to a backup tool that a lot of IT firms use. They tried it on more than 2,250 organizations’ Microsoft 365...