the general counsel's definitive guide to insurance

Reading time: 7 minutes

Welcome to the Pride,

“Our insurance carrier’s denying coverage”

Five words you never want to hear!

As General Counsel, your mandate is to protect your institution from legal and financial harm.

Few things are more frustrating than discovering your insurance might not work when you need it.

Especially when that puts your organization at risk.

Take our client, Jessica, for example. As GC of a regional financial services firm, she came to us facing a regulatory investigation with $1.8 million in potential uncovered defense costs after her carriers denied coverage.

(Jessica is not her real name)

In this guide, we'll show you how elite General Counsels like Jessica are transforming their approach to insurance.

How to ensure your insurance program supports your mandate to protect the institution
How your legal expertise can be leveraged to strengthen critical coverage areas
The three policy sections that create unexpected coverage gaps for organizations
How to test insurance contracts through a legal lens to protect organizational assets
Why meeting your claims team before signing matters more than you think
Actionable steps to ensure your insurance performs when claims hit

We want this to be the last article you ever need to read on insurance.

The GC's Insurance Paradox

As a GC you face a fascinating contradiction.

You're an expert at protecting your institution through careful contract review and negotiation.

Yet when it comes to the very insurance contracts meant to safeguard your organization, blind spots emerge in surprising places.

In our 25+ years working with General Counsels at financial institutions, we've seen this scenario play out repeatedly.

The paradox creates vulnerabilities that can cost your organization millions when claims hit.

Why Even Sophisticated Legal Minds Miss Critical Coverage Gaps

Institutional protection complexity - your role requires you to protect the organization across multiple dimensions while insurance policies may not align precisely with how liability actually arises
Coverage territory misconceptions - many GCs assume standard policies fully protect the institution, when in fact, they contain exclusions specifically targeting your industry's highest exposure areas
Technical complexity - policies contain hundreds of pages and dozens of endorsements, making critical details easy to overlook even for experienced legal practitioners
Form misalignment - standard commercial forms weren't designed with your institution's unique exposures in mind, creating inherent mismatches with your protection needs

The most sophisticated GCs recognize this misalignment and address it proactively to fulfill their institutional protection mandate.

When Your Institution's Protection Fails

Remember our client, Jessica?

The denial letters, disguised as reservation of rights letters, sat on her desk...

Her company’s D&O carrier cited a regulatory exclusion
Their professional liability policy pointed to the "in fact" fraud exclusion
Neither program affirmatively covered mounting defense costs

What started as a routine regulatory inquiry turned into an 18-month saga.

Jessica wasn't just dealing with regulators.

She was fighting to protect her organization from $1.8 million in potential uncovered defense costs that threatened to impact operations and growth.

Does this scenario give you heartburn?

Take our quick self-assessment below to see if your institution might be vulnerable to similar risk exposures.

The General Counsel's Self-Assessment

Rate your confidence in each area on a scale of 1-5.

1: Significant concern
3: Moderate confidence
5: Complete confidence

Scoring:

35-40: Your program demonstrates elite institutional protection
26-34: Your program is solid but has potential improvement areas
18-25: Your program has concerning vulnerabilities that need attention
Under 18: Your program has significant exposure requiring immediate review

The Elite GC's Approach to Institutional Protection Excellence

In this guide, we'll show you how to transform your insurance into a strategic asset for institutional protection.

Over three decades, we've seen the most sophisticated GCs master these six strategies…

1. Reverse-Engineered Program Design: Protecting the Institution First

Most insurance programs start with standard market forms.

These forms rarely align with how liability actually emerges at your institution.

Like the most forward-thinking GCs, you should take the opposite approach, applying your legal analysis skills to spot institutional vulnerabilities before they become claims.

Identify the institution's most significant liability exposures using legal risk mapping
Then analyze how regulatory, litigation, and contract claims develop in their specific industry
And design coverage to comprehensively protect the organization at each vulnerability point

Real-world Example:

A financial institution's GC modeled a hypothetical regulatory investigation combined with subsequent litigation.

They discovered their program would leave the institution with significant uncovered defense costs and investigation costs due to timing and trigger issues.

This insight allowed w program restructuring before experiencing an actual claim.

2. The Coverage Hierarchy: Building Institutional Protection Layer by Layer

Not all insurance policies carry equal weight in protecting your institution.

You should establish a clear hierarchy of coverage priorities that creates comprehensive organizational protection.

The hierarchy isn't just about which coverages to prioritize.

It’s about how they interlock to form a comprehensive shield around your institution.

Ensure seamless coordination between these coverages, particularly at the intersection points where institutional exposures are highest.

Regulatory Coverage Essentials

You should secure specific endorsements to address common regulatory exclusions that could leave your institution exposed:

Specific language that addresses coverage for informal SEC inquiries
Coverage for Civil Investigative Demands (CIDs) from CFPB and similar agencies
Protection for regulatory proceedings against the entity, not just individuals
Pre-formal investigation coverage that triggers before named parties are identified

The right endorsements can mean the difference between full institutional protection and millions in uncovered defense costs.

3. The Hidden Factor: Claims Handling vs. Premium Cost

Most organizations fixate on premium cost when evaluating carrier options.

Experienced GCs know better.

Your premium is only one component of the total cost of risk to your institution. A differentiating factor that truly impacts your organization's protection?

Claims handling.

Just as case outcomes depend on your legal strategy, claim outcomes depend on your carrier counterparty’s approach to defending your institution.

Consider this example…

A regional financial services firm selected a carrier offering premiums 23% below market for their D&O coverage.

When they experienced a significant claim…their carrier's adversarial approach and delayed responses extended litigation by 14 months, increased defense costs by over $720,000, and diverted countless executive hours.

The "savings" from the lower premium?

Dwarfed by the downstream costs of poor claims handling.

Evaluate your carrier counterparties with the same rigor you use to select outside counsel for bet-the-company litigation.

Here’s how to pick this kind of insurance counterparty:

Claims payment philosophy - does the carrier have a reputation for defending institutions like yours fairly and promptly?
Claims staff experience - do they have dedicated teams familiar with your industry's unique exposures?
Coverage interpretation approach - how do they handle policy ambiguities in scenarios common to your industry?
Financial strength - do they have the capacity to fully protect your institution against catastrophic losses?
Outside Counsel - do they automatically lawyer up or do they use their best efforts to settle?

By selecting partners based on these criteria, you can achieve significantly better protection for your institution.

4. Contractual Engineering: Aligning Policy Language with Institutional Needs

Policy wording matters.

Particularly for institutions with specialized operations not contemplated in standard forms.

You understand the critical importance of precise contract language.

At LION, we apply similar analysis to insurance contracts, ensuring the policy language precisely protects your organization where it matters most.

Each contract is unique.

Here are three critical areas that demand scrutiny to protect your institution…

Fraud Exclusions in D&O Policies:
Standard policies exclude fraudulent acts. The trigger wording makes all the difference in whether your institution remains protected during allegations. Weak exclusions allow carriers to deny coverage to your organization based on allegations, not proven facts.

Your institution's coverage should include:

"Final non-appealable adjudication" language (not "in fact" language)
Requirements that fraud must be proven in “the underlying action”
Non-rescindable Side A coverage for directors and officers
Removing any language which isn’t a legal standard like “dishonest”

Application Definitions:
Carefully review your policy provisions but don’t overlook what constitutes your institution's "application." This oversight can be devastating when carriers seek to rescind coverage for your entire organization based on alleged misrepresentations.

Your institution's coverage should include:

A narrow application definition to only include current renewal’s applications
Strong severability provisions to protect innocent parts of the organization and people
Create internal verification processes for all materials that might become part of the "application"
Limiting the look-back period for any publicly available documents to 12 months

Regulatory Coverage:
Standard policy language often creates dangerous gaps in protection for your institution during regulatory actions, potentially leaving your organization with significant uncovered defense costs.

Our suggested approach…ensure your institution's program includes:

Coverage for informal inquiries and requests for information directed at the entity
Protection for the organization during regulatory investigations, not just individuals
Coverage for internal investigations your institution must conduct in response to regulatory interest
No outright exclusions for regulatory claims

Definition Traps That Threaten Institutional Protection

Vendor and Counsel Pre-Approval: (Protecting Institutional Resources)

Negotiate pre-approved vendor and outside counsel panels during policy placement.

Not once a claim is already in progress.

This approach ensures your institution has access to advisors you trust at pre-negotiated rates when time is of the essence.

Two essential endorsements to secure for institutional protection:

'Preferred Breach Coach Endorsement' - Names your chosen cybersecurity firms and incident response teams with automatic approval
'Outside Counsel Panel Addendum' - Establishes agreed billing rates and approval protocols for your trusted defense firms

These endorsements eliminate debates about counsel selection during crisis situations.

5. Six-Month Renewal Orchestration: Securing the Best Institutional Protection

Most institutions approach renewals reactively, beginning 90 days before expiration.

This compressed timeline forces them into a position of weakness.

Implement a strategic, 150-day renewal process that ensures your institution secures optimal protection and has time to deal with any unforeseen issues that always seem to arise at the 11th hour.

(Like that circumstance that could give rise to a claim that you only found out about a week before the renewal date!)

Days 150-120: Risk Assessment

Schedule renewal strategy meetings with risk stakeholders
Perform comprehensive institutional exposure analysis
Complete marketplace reviews and carrier evaluations
Develop submission strategies highlighting institutional strengths

Days 120-90: Protection Strategy

Conduct renewal strategy meetings with key institutional stakeholders
Align on strategy and marketing plans for optimal organizational protection
Finalize applications and submission materials that position your institution favorably

Days 90-60: Market Engagement

Submit to selected carriers with institutional protection priorities clearly defined
Conduct preliminary negotiations emphasizing your organization's specific needs
Provide regular updates to leadership on protection enhancement progress

Days 60-30: Coverage Analysis

Evaluate quotes and terms against institutional protection benchmarks
Complete subjectivities with focus on maintaining favorable terms
Prepare comprehensive renewal proposals that clearly communicate protection levels

Days 30-0: Implementation

Present final options to leadership with clear explanation of institutional benefits
Bind coverage with optimal protection for your organization
Distribute policies and coverage summaries to key stakeholders

This extended timeline provides a strategic advantage.

Your institution approaches the market from a position of strength rather than necessity positioning your institution to secure the most comprehensive protection available.

It also gives your underwriters time to thoroughly evaluate your submission rather than forcing them to make quick, conservative decisions that aggravate all sides.

6. Measuring Success: The General Counsel's Institutional Protection Dashboard

How do you know if your insurance program truly delivers protection for your institution?

You should track these specific metrics that measure organizational protection…

Total Cost of Risk (TCOR) as a Percentage of Revenue - this comprehensive metric includes premiums paid, self-insured losses, risk management expenses, and claims administration expenses to quantify the institutional investment in protection.

Coverage Coordination Score - use our proprietary metrics that evaluate how seamlessly your various policies work together to protect the organization, identifying potential gaps or overlaps at critical intersection points such as:

Entity coverage across multiple policies
Coverage for emerging institutional risks
Industry-specific exposure protection

Institutional Protection Rating - assesses the degree to which your program addresses the specific exposures and regulatory requirements facing your organization.

Claims Recovery Ratio - measuring the percentage of institutional losses ultimately recovered through your insurance program. Target recovery ratios above 80% for covered claims.

Renewal Efficiency Index - tracking resources expended during the renewal process, including executive time commitment, documentation burden, information request response time, and submission quality.

Organizational Resilience Score - forward-looking measures that assess how effectively your insurance program would respond to scenarios that threaten your institution's operations and reputation. Implementing table-top exercises throughout the renewal process is key to obtaining a high score.

By tracking these metrics over a couple of renewal cycles, elite GCs transform insurance from a transaction into a strategic asset that strengthens institutional protection year over year.

Want to learn more about these tools? We’ll show you where to start. Book a 1:1 call with us to see our process in action.

How Jessica's Story Ended: Securing Institutional Protection

Remember Jessica, our client from the financial services firm?

After 18 months of massive frustration, she sought specialized help from us to protect her institution.

Here’s how our team turned her situation around.

Phase 1: Damage Control

Assembled our claims advocacy team with regulatory expertise
Conducted comprehensive analysis of both coverage programs to identify institutional protection opportunities
Found policy sections that supported coverage for her organization despite unclear wording
Leveraged senior relationships to escalate above frontline adjusters

Phase 2: Strategic Negotiation

Presented comprehensive coverage analysis highlighting policy ambiguities affecting her institutional protection
Applied relevant legal principles to address policy ambiguities in her institution's favor
Facilitated direct discussions between the carrier's senior management and the executive team to resolve issues threatening the organization’s position in the markets

Phase 3: Program Restructuring

Created clear protection paths for the institution across all coverage areas
Replaced convoluted policy language with streamlined manuscript forms designed for institutional protection
Reduced documentation from 230+ pages to under 40 pages of clear, actionable coverage
Structured excess layers to truly follow form on key provisions protecting the organization
Moved coverage to carriers with proven track records of defending similar institutions

The Results

Within three months:

Carriers agreed to cover the claim, protecting the organization's finances
The company saved over $1.8 million in potential exposures that would have impacted operations
Legal fees for coverage disputes disappeared, allowing focus on core business
Executive time refocused on strategic initiatives benefiting the institution
The restructured program closed all identified gaps in institutional protection
Renewal negotiations began six months in advance with comprehensive submission materials
New claim protocols established with carriers to prevent future disputes that could threaten institutional interests

If you’re experiencing a similar claims issue, contact us for a 1:1 call. Better yet, don’t take our word for it, reach out for a referral to discuss with our client the “real Jessica.”

The General Counsel's Strategic Insurance Framework

Your insurance program should directly support your mandate to protect your institution across multiple dimensions.

White Glove Service: Why Specialized Expertise Matters

The most sophisticated General Counsels recognize a fundamental reality.

Despite their extensive legal knowledge, specialized insurance advisors bring essential perspective, strategy, and execution to strengthen institutional protection.

This manifests in several ways...

1. Technical depth and institutional coverage acumen

Understanding protection needs specific to your industry and business model
Knowledge of market appetite for your organization's risk profile
Tracking of emerging claim trends affecting institutions like yours
Monitoring of court decisions impacting coverage for your industry

2. Proprietary analytics and institutional benchmarking

Data-driven insights supporting enhanced organizational protection
Peer benchmarking specific to similar institutions
Claims trend analysis identifying emerging institutional exposures
Carrier performance metrics evaluating defense of similar organizations

3. Market access and leverage for institutional benefit

Relationships with markets having appetite for your industry's risks
Ability to counter adverse underwriting assumptions with historical performance data
Identification of alternative risk transfer options for difficult-to-place institutional exposures
Strategic timing of submissions to capitalize on market conditions

4. Claims advocacy as institutional protection

Deep understanding of coverage interpretations specific to your industry
Relationships with senior claims personnel at key carriers
Experience with similar claim scenarios informing resolution strategies
Resources to analyze complex coverage interactions affecting organizational protection

5. Proactive risk intelligence focused on institutional threats

Industry-specific updates on emerging trends
Regulatory bulletins highlighting evolving institutional exposures
Peer network insights revealing common challenges in your sector
Thought leadership illuminating evolving institutional protection practices

Ready to transform your organization's insurance process? Let's talk.

Your Path Forward: Four Steps to Institutional Excellence

You can transform your insurance program from a necessary expense into a strategic advantage for your institution.

The execution begins with these four steps.

1. Comprehensive Institutional Assessment

Identify coverage gaps that could expose your organization to significant losses
Evaluate how your policies work together to protect the institution
Review your application materials to minimize institutional rescission risk

2. Strategic Protection Roadmap Development

Prioritize coverage enhancements based on institutional exposure severity and probability
Create a phased implementation plan aligned with renewal cycles
Establish metrics for ongoing institutional protection evaluation

3. Implementation and Execution

Initiate renewal process 150 days before expiration to ensure optimal protection
Engage underwriters based on strategic carrier selection and execute a focused negotiation strategy
Document program structure and coverage intent for organizational clarity

4. Ongoing Institutional Protection Optimization

Track key performance metrics that measure organizational protection
Conduct annual stress testing using institution-specific scenarios
Update program based on emerging industry exposures

The Bottom Line

With over three decades of experience and more than $250 million in claims recoveries for clients, we bring specialized expertise to General Counsels seeking to strengthen their institutional protection.

Ready to transform your organization's insurance program? Let's talk.

Not quite ready to talk…?

Check out our personal asset protection blueprint.

If you're a director or officer at an FI - your personal assets are on the line if your company faces a major claim.

That's why we created the D&O Contract Vigilance Blueprint. It’s a 5-day email course to help you:

Secure better D&O insurance: Learn how to avoid common policy mistakes and identify overlooked coverage gaps.
Protect your personal assets: Understand your potential liability and take steps to mitigate your risks.

>>> Get the D&O Contract Vigilance Blueprint

Don't wait until a claim hits to find out your institution is under-protected.

Thank you for reading today's edition!

Want to share this edition via text, email or social media?

Simply copy-and-paste the link below:

https://lionspecialty.kit.com/posts/the-general-counsel-s-definitive-guide-to-insurance

And if you got this newsletter forwarded, you can subscribe here.

Stay Covered,

Natasha & Mark
Co-Founders and Managing Partners
LION Specialty

Disclaimer: The insights, analyses, and opinions expressed in this article are solely those of LION Specialty and do not constitute legal advice.

Please consult the specific terms, conditions, and exclusions of your own insurance policies and a professional team like ours before acting on any information contained herein.

LION Specialty